Hard west combat injuries4/28/2023 ![]() That’s why standards are applied individually if an individual can meet the qualifying standard, he or she should be permitted to do the job. Most average Americans cannot meet the basic eligibility standards to join the military applying Mac Donald’s logic to that fact and ceasing to allow any Americans into the armed services more clearly demonstrates her logic’s absurdity. But an average is no reason to categorically ban a population. We are physiologically different and, on average, a man’s body can handle more weight and physical hardship than a woman’s. Mac Donald is correct in asserting that men’s and women’s bodies are different. ![]() They need to fix their standards problem. The US military’s combat arms branches do not need to ban women. While I agree with many of her premises and beliefs, I disagree with her conclusion. Last month, Heather Mac Donald’s Wall Street Journal op-ed argued that “women don’t belong in combat units.” In it, Mac Donald makes four main claims: first, that women are physiologically incapable of handling combat second, that women cannot meet physical standards next, that the “inevitable introduction of eros” will erode unit cohesion and, finally, that military policies should only be made to improve combat effectiveness. Women serving in combat roles is no exception: implementation and standards should be addressed, but the policy aim is right. Just because policies take time and adjustments to “get it right” does not mean that they should be abandoned altogether. It took America more than 130 years to declare that men and women should have equal voting rights. It took the US Supreme Court almost sixty years to decide that “separate but equal” was anything but equal and black Americans should attend school alongside white ones. It took the US cavalry twenty-five years to accept that armored tanks were better than horses against a machine gun. It took the US infantry fifty-five years and thousands of deaths to abandon the idea of trench warfare.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |